Sheumas, Boyd, Kyle, Stewart and Lucy MacNeil: The Barra MacNeils
It’s Remembrance Day but already Lucy MacNeil has been busy gearing up for Christmas. Two days from now she and her brothers, uumas, Kyle, Stewart, and Boyd, will be at the Mary Winspear Centre in Sidney, British Columbia to kick off their Christmas Tour as part of the Barra MacNeil’s 40th Anniversary. I was lucky to have a bit of time to chat with Lucy, via Zoom, in between all of her last minute errands.
The Barra MacNeils hail from Sydney Mines, Nova Scotia, and the six siblings grew up in a musical family. Their music, a mixture of traditional Irish and Scottish songs and tunes and contemporary folk songs bolstered by an impressive array of instruments played by all the siblings, has made them one of the provinces’ most beloved mainstays in the music industry. Their Christmas tours, especially, have become a favourite tradition for families across the country.
For Lucy MacNeil the ways that the touring, especially at Christmastime, has needed to be managed has changed over the years. She started touring before she had her children, and then when they were little she needed to plunk them down early in front of the Sears Wishbook to make sure they had circled all their toy choices for Santa. “That was my priority- their dresses for their Christmas concert at school…” she says. Now that her children are young adults she is finding that she needs to focus more on getting herself ready for the long periods of sitting down in a tour bus, and making sure all her muscles and joints are limber so that she has that flexibility for the step dancing once she hits the stage. These are new considerations that come after 40 years on the road.
There is a little bit of stress before the tour starts concerning their instruments because they send some of them on ahead by truck, as the band will be flying to British Columbia, and it’s much easier to do that without larger instruments- like Lucy’s harp, for example. This means that she had to be organized to make sure that most of her rehearsal for the harp pieces was finished first. “When we get [to BC] there’s getting all of us on the bus, and then getting all our stuff from where it’s been sent, and hoping everything is there- so there’s a lot of steps before we actually do the first show. I find once you get those first two shows under your belt the organization is better.”
For many years their cousin Nick travelled with them and handled the merchandise table, where you can buy not just CDs and vinyl records, but aprons, Christmas Tree ornaments, and all sorts of goodies and stocking stuffers. This year they have someone new handling the merch. “It’s nice because there’s something a little different [about the bus experience]- new stories- there’s many hours, some days, just sitting there- some are sleeping, but usually there’s somebody up and just a lot of talking and finding out [about one another]- it can be very interesting.”
For years before the Barras released their self titled debut album in 1986 they were all busy singing in different choirs. “Growing up everybody is going to a different mass because I was in the girls’ choir, and some of the boys were in the boys’ choir, and mum was in the adult choir… so we always had [Christmas] songs that we knew. And our Uncle Charlie, he was a singer. I remember him coming and us all doing the “Gloria” parts… and the boys always played [on] Boxing Day at a pub (now called Monty’s), so that came to be a big tradition- so you incorporate Christmassy things into the other stuff that you were doing.” Sometimes Lucy would join her brothers at the pub too when she was still in school, for a few tunes or to get up and step dance. She says this was especially memorable at Christmas because she would see people gathered there with their families who had come home to Nova Scotia for the holidays from working or studying away. “I remember my mother, [Jean] saying one time, because mom and dad would be there as well, she’d look up and point out all the ones that she had taught step dancing to over the years, and they’d all be up dancing. It was really, really nice.” She says that when she thinks back to those early days she can see how they built up their Christmas repertoire, but they wouldn’t have ever imagined how Christmas would become such a cornerstone to their careers.
Lucy began playing the harp because of its association with Clan MacNeil, and the Clan MacNeil in Canada, who purchased a harp and wanted a MacNeil to learn it and to be able to teach others. “I was still in High School, and that summer I went with mom and dad and Ryan and Boyd to Houlton, Maine. That was the year Island Love Song (1987) was being filmed.
mas, Kyle, and Stewart were in it as the MacNeil Brothers, and they played some music for it, so they would have gone to Toronto to do some recording with the musical director,” explains Lucy. Their family van was being used for that, so her father, Columba, rented a station wagon from a company called Rent-a-Wreck. “We took the harp and all of us and a tent, and we went to Houlton, Maine, and we stayed in the tent. This was the end of June- the days were nice and warm, but the nights were cold, and dad would carry my harp across the field over to this house- Jay Witcher was the name of the harp maker, and Jane was his wife… they had this harp camp, and my teacher was Elizabeth Hannan; she was from Ireland.” Lucy was originally supposed to study with Caitrìona Yeats, granddaughter of William Butler Yeats, but she wasn’t able to come. “Every day for a week I would go for an hour and get some instruction, and I never left with a tune, it was all about trying to get the technique.” She still didn’t feel very secure when she left, so she continued to teach herself from books. She says that playing the harp in Cape Breton is a bit more common now, but was very uncommon when she was a teenager. She also plays the fiddle, where she especially loved playing the slower airs, and she tends to lean towards the Irish style. She says that there’s an element of comfort during the Barra concerts because she is playing with her brothers, literally “second fiddle,” she jokes. But now with her solo projects she finds herself needing to practice quite a bit more. She says it’s so encouraging now to see all the young fiddlers coming up throughout Cape Breton, and especially to see how many of the young fiddlers are girls.

In 1993 Lucy, Sheumas, Kyle, and Stewart were featured on Rita MacNeil’s Christmas special Once Upon a Christmas where they performed arrangements of “O Holy Night,” “Angels We Have Heard On High,” and “God Rest Ye Merry Gentleman.” They received a lot of positive feedback from this performance and that eventually led to them releasing The Christmas Album (1999), and then The Christmas Album II (2006), and O Christmas Three (2013). The albums have really cemented the band as an essential soundtrack of the season for folks not just in Nova Scotia but across the country and beyond. They started their Christmas Tour 26 years ago with two vans, which was a challenge because if someone caught a bug it was much more likely to affect everyone because they were in such close proximity to one another.
When Lucy’s children were young the band would do one year of regional touring at Christmas and then one year of national touring so that she could get in as many Christmas traditions at home in as possible. “One year we were in New Hampshire, and everybody got on the bus and drove to Saint John, New Brunswick. I went to bed [there], got a taxi at 6:00am, took a flight home, someone picked me up [at the airport], so I got to see [my daughters’] Christmas concert that night. We went home, and I got them up in the morning, and got them ready for school, I brought them to school, and Priscilla Lotherington, a good friend who does the driving for Celtic Colours, she picked me up and drove me to Fredericton, and I was there for the [show] there.” She was able to make this work because there hadn’t been a show in Saint John, just a stopover. “It’s nice because then there’s a memory of it- you were there, and there’s a picture, so sometimes [the effort] is well worth it. Those memories are probably much more vivid [for my kids] than what they got for Christmas that year. It made life interesting.”
A newer tradition that she has been doing with her daughters and stepson is wallpapering the entry into where the Christmas tree is with wrapping paper and watching the three of them burst in to begin the festivities. “Then the dog [Luka] came along, and the dog got into it too. … It’s fun. You’re never too old to have a bit of fun.” She says that even with all the work involved she has gotten just as much good out of every special Christmas memory she’s made with her kids as they have. In channeling a bit the spirit of their version of the Stan Rogers song “At Last I’m Ready for Christmas” she says one year she had everything ready, and the wallpaper up and the children were asleep, “and you’re trying to do everything to be quiet, but [then I realized] the manager was in with the tree, and the baby Jesus wasn’t in the manger.” She had been told that you’re not supposed to put the Baby Jesus in the manager until Christmas Eve, so here she was on Christmas Eve having wallpapered herself out of the room with the Nativity Scene before putting little Jesus to bed. “I had to peel all the paper off- and this is probably five thirty in the morning- quarter to six- … so those are the things you do.”

Her mother also loved Christmas and always wanted to have a little something to give to everyone. She loved to decorate the Christmas tree herself, and she had specific designs and colours that she would change every decade or so. One year when she was pregnant with one of Lucy’s brothers she pushed the tree gently back into place after decorating it- it fell over. It’s often the very last thing that you’re rushing to do where something goes wrong. Having an artificial Christmas tree is another way that Lucy is able to get ready early in the season before she heads off for the tour. She is also able to leave it up longer once she comes home. This also gives them all more time to take photographs together in front of the tree as the family gathers together. Their final show of the season is December 22, 2026 at the Savoy Theatre in Glace Bay.
As a child Lucy remembers one year really wanting the smaller version of the Barbie camper. Once when she was poking around in the closet she spotted it there, and she kept wanting to go back and take another peek. Then Stewart caught her. The MacNeils would sometimes attend midnight mass, sometimes morning mass, and they would have their own Christmas at their house, and then they would load up the station wagon with gifts, and diapers, and food, and toys and clothes- everything they would need for a carload of children- and they would drive to their grandparents’ house in Washabuck Bridge. “It was a lot getting there, and snowy, and you couldn’t see the driveway- it was a long one- and you’d have to have a pretty good rig to get to the top. So, you’d stay at the bottom, and then you’d have to take a couple of trips with the toboggan- taking kids and taking groceries [up to the house].” She says that sometimes when her mother would take her grandmother, Nana, for shopping excursions, to the hairdresser, or for doctor’s appointments in the winter they would put her on the toboggan too. “Every now and again she’d have a little tip over, and she’d just laugh and laugh.”
She says that her father was recently listening to a cassette tape that they had recorded during a series of parties “at the bridge” in the 1970s, and Lucy could hear all her aunts, uncles, and her parents singing all these different songs together. “And then Maxie, Maxie Dan Angus MacNeil is what they called him, he would go into Gàidhlig songs, and [singing] all those old popular songs, and then my Uncle Hector [MacKenzie], he was very comical, and he would always add some verses to some of these songs, and usually it had to do with somebody in the area and something that happened. So, when you listen to it now, it’s almost like a little bit of history… and everybody’s laughing. … Dad’s 91 now, and [listening to the cassette] brings him right back to being there. It’s just how good it is for the soul- the singing always is such a pulse. It wasn’t all fiddle tunes- it was a lot of singing. They loved singing. That works its way into us, and into our shows.”

She says that after so many years of touring she has found that she and her brothers have relaxed into their shows, and she has realized that audiences enjoy seeing them reacting spontaneously on stage, and that if something goes awry that’s okay too. “People just want to see you be real and human.. Coming home after a tour, the relief of getting home is wonderful, but it does do something for you to bring that bit of joy to people. It’s a nice gift to be able to do that for people.” She says that she feels the appreciation from fans, whether it’s them sending messages on social media or when she sees people in person they often speak about how the music over the years has become such a special part of their lives. The band also tries their best to honour the requests they get to shout out birthdays, and to do dedications during the shows too- although Lucy advises that folks send reminders, just in case, closer to the date of the show they are attending. “We’ve had people come up and say, ‘My grandparents brought me [to your shows] and now I’m bringing my grandchildren.” It’s really become an annual tradition for entire families.
The Christmas shows are a nice mix of traditional/more religious music and secular songs too. She says that the Barras played at a friend’s daughter’s bat mitzvah once in Ontario, and then she brought her entire class to the Christmas concert when the band came through Toronto. “People say that it feels like they were at a party in our home,” she says. “There’s reverence and there’s fun, without being preachy. It’s not about the stuff, but about your people, even your neighbours, and reaching out to those that may be alone. That’s the biggest thing. I think people go home with that message and it’s that feeling – it’s not that they were wowed- it’s more about the feeling they got more than anything. You don’t have to be the best at singing or the best at playing because someone that just loves music, or maybe they just learned themselves, if they can perform and it comes from the heart, you can get a wonderful feeling from it.”
Luckily for audiences at the Barra MacNeil’s Christmas shows they will be both wowed and filled with the infectious joy of the Christmas spirit by the time they head home.
The Barra MacNeils’ Christmas Tour continues from now until December 22nd. Tonight, November 18th they are in Oliver, British Columbia at the Venables Theatre (6100 Gala Street). The tour continues with nearly 30 more stops including (but not at all limited to) Calgary, Saskatoon, Winnipeg, Thunder Bay, Ottawa, and Massey Hall in Toronto on December 18th. They will be in Halifax at the Rebecca Cohn Auditorium December 20th for shows at both 3:00pm and 7:30pm (they’re nearly sold out!), and then they head home to the Savoy Theatre for shows December 21st and 22nd at 7:00pm. For more information about buying tickets, to see the full concert lineup, and for all other information please visit this website. You can find the Barra’s albums here.
Canadian Arts Journalism is an essential part of a healthy and thriving community. It helps artists find new audiences for their shows, deepens audiences’ engagement with local artists and the work being created in their communities, and it is one of the best ways to preserve a snapshot of an ephemeral art form for future generations. TWISI relies on support from its Subscribers, folks like you who care about the survival of local and independent arts coverage. Please consider becoming a Subscriber today, or click here for more information. Thank you so much for supporting TWISI.
